Court Recognizes Reservation Status of Three Oklahoma Tribes

Three tribal nations in Oklahoma had their reservations deemed "never disestablished" last week by the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals.

Winston Whitecrow Brester, a citizen of the Seneca-Cayuga Nation, filed for post-conviction relief in November 2020 over crimes he was convicted of between 2018 and 2020 in Ottawa County. Brester claimed that since his crimes were committed on the Ottawa, Peoria and Miami Tribe's reservations, he should be tried in federal court, not state court — per the landmark McGirt v. Oklahoma ruling in 2020 that established that crimes committed by Native Americans on tribal lands fall under the jurisdiction of the tribal nations and federal courts.

In response, the state filed an opposing motion, claiming that the reservations in question had been disestablished by termination-era policies in the 1950s, and the state, therefore, had the right to prosecute Brester. The termination era —which spanned the 1940s and 1960s — was defined by policies that sought to terminate the government's trusteeship over Indian reservations under the guise the liberating Tribal nations from federal control. However, those policies and measures failed and the federal government ultimately reinstated tribal nation's sovereign status, including the Peoria and Ottawa tribes.

https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/court-recognizes-reservation-status-of-three-oklahoma-tribes